btrfs-man5 - topics about the BTRFS filesystem (mount options, supported file attributes and other)
This document describes topics related to BTRFS that are not specific to the tools. Currently covers:
This section describes mount options specific to BTRFS. For the generic mount options please refer to mount(8) manpage. The options are sorted alphabetically (discarding the no prefix).
most mount options apply to the whole filesystem and only options in the first mounted subvolume will take effect. This is due to lack of implementation and may change in the future. This means that (for example) you can’t set per-subvolume nodatacow, nodatasum, or compress using mount options. This should eventually be fixed, but it has proved to be difficult to implement correctly within the Linux VFS framework.
Mount options are processed in order, only the last occurrence of an option takes effect and may disable other options due to constraints (see eg. nodatacow and compress). The output of mount command shows which options have been applied.
Enable/disable support for Posix Access Control Lists (ACLs). See the acl(5) manual page for more information about ACLs.
The support for ACL is build-time configurable (BTRFS_FS_POSIX_ACL) and mount fails if acl is requested but the feature is not compiled in.
Enable automatic file defragmentation. When enabled, small random writes into files (in a range of tens of kilobytes, currently it’s 64K) are detected and queued up for the defragmentation process. Not well suited for large database workloads.
The read latency may increase due to reading the adjacent blocks that make up the range for defragmentation, successive write will merge the blocks in the new location.
Defragmenting with Linux kernel versions < 3.9 or ≥ 3.14-rc2 as well as with Linux stable kernel versions ≥ 3.10.31, ≥ 3.12.12 or ≥ 3.13.4 will break up the reflinks of COW data (for example files copied with cp --reflink, snapshots or de-duplicated data). This may cause considerable increase of space usage depending on the broken up reflinks.
Ensure that all IO write operations make it through the device cache and are stored permanently when the filesystem is at its consistency checkpoint. This typically means that a flush command is sent to the device that will synchronize all pending data and ordinary metadata blocks, then writes the superblock and issues another flush.
The write flushes incur a slight hit and also prevent the IO block scheduler to reorder requests in a more effective way. Disabling barriers gets rid of that penalty but will most certainly lead to a corrupted filesystem in case of a crash or power loss. The ordinary metadata blocks could be yet unwritten at the time the new superblock is stored permanently, expecting that the block pointers to metadata were stored permanently before.
On a device with a volatile battery-backed write-back cache, the nobarrier option will not lead to filesystem corruption as the pending blocks are supposed to make it to the permanent storage.
check_int, check_int_data, check_int_print_mask=value
These debugging options control the behavior of the integrity checking module (the BTRFS_FS_CHECK_INTEGRITY config option required). The main goal is to verify that all blocks from a given transaction period are properly linked.
check_int enables the integrity checker module, which examines all block write requests to ensure on-disk consistency, at a large memory and CPU cost.
check_int_data includes extent data in the integrity checks, and implies the check_int option.
check_int_print_mask takes a bitmask of BTRFSIC_PRINT_MASK_* values as defined in fs/btrfs/check-integrity.c, to control the integrity checker module behavior.
See comments at the top of fs/btrfs/check-integrity.c for more information.
Set the interval of periodic transaction commit when data are synchronized to permanent storage. Higher interval values lead to larger amount of unwritten data, which has obvious consequences when the system crashes. The upper bound is not forced, but a warning is printed if it’s more than 300 seconds (5 minutes). Use with care.
compress, compress=type[:level], compress-force, compress-force=type[:level]
Control BTRFS file data compression. Type may be specified as zlib, lzo, zstd or no (for no compression, used for remounting). If no type is specified, zlib is used. If compress-force is specified, then compression will always be attempted, but the data may end up uncompressed if the compression would make them larger.
Both zlib and zstd (since version 5.1) expose the compression level as a tunable knob with higher levels trading speed and memory (zstd) for higher compression ratios. This can be set by appending a colon and the desired level. Zlib accepts the range [1, 9] and zstd accepts [1, 15]. If no level is set, both currently use a default level of 3. The value 0 is an alias for the default level.
Otherwise some simple heuristics are applied to detect an incompressible file. If the first blocks written to a file are not compressible, the whole file is permanently marked to skip compression. As this is too simple, the compress-force is a workaround that will compress most of the files at the cost of some wasted CPU cycles on failed attempts. Since kernel 4.15, a set of heuristic algorithms have been improved by using frequency sampling, repeated pattern detection and Shannon entropy calculation to avoid that.
If compression is enabled, nodatacow and nodatasum are disabled.
Enable data copy-on-write for newly created files. Nodatacow implies nodatasum, and disables compression. All files created under nodatacow are also set the NOCOW file attribute (see chattr(1)).
If nodatacow or nodatasum are enabled, compression is disabled.
Enable data checksumming for newly created files. Datasum implies datacow, ie. the normal mode of operation. All files created under nodatasum inherit the "no checksums" property, however there’s no corresponding file attribute (see chattr(1)).
If nodatacow or nodatasum are enabled, compression is disabled.
Allow mounts with less devices than the RAID profile constraints require. A read-write mount (or remount) may fail when there are too many devices missing, for example if a stripe member is completely missing from RAID0.
Since 4.14, the constraint checks have been improved and are verified on the chunk level, not an the device level. This allows degraded mounts of filesystems with mixed RAID profiles for data and metadata, even if the device number constraints would not be satisfied for some of the profiles.
Example: metadata — raid1, data — single, devices — /dev/sda, /dev/sdb
Suppose the data are completely stored on sda, then missing sdb will not prevent the mount, even if 1 missing device would normally prevent (any) single profile to mount. In case some of the data chunks are stored on sdb, then the constraint of single/data is not satisfied and the filesystem cannot be mounted.
booting eg. a RAID1 system may fail even if all filesystem’s device paths are provided as the actual device nodes may not be discovered by the system at that point.
discard, discard=sync, discard=async, nodiscard
Enable discarding of freed file blocks. This is useful for SSD devices, thinly provisioned LUNs, or virtual machine images; however, every storage layer must support discard for it to work.
In the synchronous mode (sync or without option value), lack of asynchronous queued TRIM on the backing device TRIM can severely degrade performance, because a synchronous TRIM operation will be attempted instead. Queued TRIM requires newer than SATA revision 3.1 chipsets and devices.
The asynchronous mode (async) gathers extents in larger chunks before sending them to the devices for TRIM. The overhead and performance impact should be negligible compared to the previous mode and it’s supposed to be the preferred mode if needed.
If it is not necessary to immediately discard freed blocks, then the fstrim tool can be used to discard all free blocks in a batch. Scheduling a TRIM during a period of low system activity will prevent latent interference with the performance of other operations. Also, a device may ignore the TRIM command if the range is too small, so running a batch discard has a greater probability of actually discarding the blocks.
Enable verbose output for some ENOSPC conditions. It’s safe to use but can be noisy if the system reaches near-full state.
Action to take when encountering a fatal error.
This option forces any data dirtied by a write in a prior transaction to commit as part of the current commit, effectively a full filesystem sync.
This makes the committed state a fully consistent view of the file system from the application’s perspective (i.e. it includes all completed file system operations). This was previously the behavior only when a snapshot was created.
When off, the filesystem is consistent but buffered writes may last more than one transaction commit.
A debugging helper to intentionally fragment given type of block groups. The type can be data, metadata or all. This mount option should not be used outside of debugging environments and is not recognized if the kernel config option BTRFS_DEBUG is not enabled.
The tree-log contains pending updates to the filesystem until the full commit. The log is replayed on next mount, this can be disabled by this option. See also treelog. Note that nologreplay is the same as norecovery.
currently, the tree log is replayed even with a read-only mount! To disable that behaviour, mount also with nologreplay.
Specify the maximum amount of space, that can be inlined in a metadata B-tree leaf. The value is specified in bytes, optionally with a K suffix (case insensitive). In practice, this value is limited by the filesystem block size (named sectorsize at mkfs time), and memory page size of the system. In case of sectorsize limit, there’s some space unavailable due to leaf headers. For example, a 4k sectorsize, maximum size of inline data is about 3900 bytes.
Inlining can be completely turned off by specifying 0. This will increase data block slack if file sizes are much smaller than block size but will reduce metadata consumption in return.
the default value has changed to 2048 in kernel 4.6.
Specifies that 1 metadata chunk should be allocated after every value data chunks. Default behaviour depends on internal logic, some percent of unused metadata space is attempted to be maintained but is not always possible if there’s not enough space left for chunk allocation. The option could be useful to override the internal logic in favor of the metadata allocation if the expected workload is supposed to be metadata intense (snapshots, reflinks, xattrs, inlined files).
Do not attempt any data recovery at mount time. This will disable logreplay and avoids other write operations. Note that this option is the same as nologreplay.
The opposite option recovery used to have different meaning but was changed for consistency with other filesystems, where norecovery is used for skipping log replay. BTRFS does the same and in general will try to avoid any write operations.
Force check and rebuild procedure of the UUID tree. This should not normally be needed.
Modes allowing mount with damaged filesystem structures.
Skip automatic resume of an interrupted balance operation. The operation can later be resumed with btrfs balance resume, or the paused state can be removed with btrfs balance cancel. The default behaviour is to resume an interrupted balance immediately after a volume is mounted.
space_cache, space_cache=version, nospace_cache
Options to control the free space cache. The free space cache greatly improves performance when reading block group free space into memory. However, managing the space cache consumes some resources, including a small amount of disk space.
There are two implementations of the free space cache. The original one, referred to as v1, is the safe default. The v1 space cache can be disabled at mount time with nospace_cache without clearing.
On very large filesystems (many terabytes) and certain workloads, the performance of the v1 space cache may degrade drastically. The v2 implementation, which adds a new B-tree called the free space tree, addresses this issue. Once enabled, the v2 space cache will always be used and cannot be disabled unless it is cleared. Use clear_cache,space_cache=v1 or clear_cache,nospace_cache to do so. If v2 is enabled, kernels without v2 support will only be able to mount the filesystem in read-only mode.
If a version is not explicitly specified, the default implementation will be chosen, which is v1.
ssd, ssd_spread, nossd, nossd_spread
Options to control SSD allocation schemes. By default, BTRFS will enable or disable SSD optimizations depending on status of a device with respect to rotational or non-rotational type. This is determined by the contents of /sys/block/DEV/queue/rotational). If it is 0, the ssd option is turned on. The option nossd will disable the autodetection.
The optimizations make use of the absence of the seek penalty that’s inherent for the rotational devices. The blocks can be typically written faster and are not offloaded to separate threads.
Since 4.14, the block layout optimizations have been dropped. This used to help with first generations of SSD devices. Their FTL (flash translation layer) was not effective and the optimization was supposed to improve the wear by better aligning blocks. This is no longer true with modern SSD devices and the optimization had no real benefit. Furthermore it caused increased fragmentation. The layout tuning has been kept intact for the option ssd_spread.
if both subvolid and subvol are specified, they must point at the same subvolume, otherwise the mount will fail.
The number of worker threads to start. NRCPUS is number of on-line CPUs detected at the time of mount. Small number leads to less parallelism in processing data and metadata, higher numbers could lead to a performance hit due to increased locking contention, process scheduling, cache-line bouncing or costly data transfers between local CPU memories.
Enable the tree logging used for fsync and O_SYNC writes. The tree log stores changes without the need of a full filesystem sync. The log operations are flushed at sync and transaction commit. If the system crashes between two such syncs, the pending tree log operations are replayed during mount.
currently, the tree log is replayed even with a read-only mount! To disable that behaviour, also mount with nologreplay.
Enable autorecovery attempts if a bad tree root is found at mount time. Currently this scans a backup list of several previous tree roots and tries to use the first readable. This can be used with read-only mounts as well.
This option has replaced recovery.
Allow subvolumes to be deleted by their respective owner. Otherwise, only the root user can do that.
historically, any user could create a snapshot even if he was not owner of the source subvolume, the subvolume deletion has been restricted for that reason. The subvolume creation has been restricted but this mount option is still required. This is a usability issue. Since 4.18, the rmdir(2) syscall can delete an empty subvolume just like an ordinary directory. Whether this is possible can be detected at runtime, see rmdir_subvol feature in FILESYSTEM FEATURES.
List of mount options that have been removed, kept for backward compatibility.
this option has been replaced by usebackuproot and should not be used but will work on 4.5+ kernels.
the functionality has been removed in 5.11, any stale data created by previous use of the inode_cache option can be removed by btrfs check --clear-ino-cache.
Some of the general mount options from mount(8) that affect BTRFS and are worth mentioning.
Note that noatime may break applications that rely on atime uptimes like the venerable Mutt (unless you use maildir mailboxes).
The basic set of filesystem features gets extended over time. The backward compatibility is maintained and the features are optional, need to be explicitly asked for so accidental use will not create incompatibilities.
There are several classes and the respective tools to manage the features:
at mkfs time only
after mkfs, on an unmounted filesystem
after mkfs, on a mounted filesystem
Whether a particular feature can be turned on a mounted filesystem can be found in the directory /sys/fs/btrfs/features/, one file per feature. The value 1 means the feature can be enabled.
List of features (see also mkfs.btrfs(8) section FILESYSTEM FEATURES):
the filesystem uses nodesize for metadata blocks, this can be bigger than the page size
the lzo compression has been used on the filesystem, either as a mount option or via btrfs filesystem defrag.
the zstd compression has been used on the filesystem, either as a mount option or via btrfs filesystem defrag.
the default subvolume has been set on the filesystem
increased hardlink limit per file in a directory to 65536, older kernels supported a varying number of hardlinks depending on the sum of all file name sizes that can be stored into one metadata block
free space representation using a dedicated b-tree, successor of v1 space cache
the main filesystem UUID is the metadata_uuid, which stores the new UUID only in the superblock while all metadata blocks still have the UUID set at mkfs time, see btrfstune(8) for more
the last major disk format change, improved backreferences, now default
mixed data and metadata block groups, ie. the data and metadata are not separated and occupy the same block groups, this mode is suitable for small volumes as there are no constraints how the remaining space should be used (compared to the split mode, where empty metadata space cannot be used for data and vice versa)
on the other hand, the final layout is quite unpredictable and possibly highly fragmented, which means worse performance
improved representation of file extents where holes are not explicitly stored as an extent, saves a few percent of metadata if sparse files are used
extended RAID1 mode with copies on 3 or 4 devices respectively
the filesystem contains or contained a raid56 profile of block groups
indicate that rmdir(2) syscall can delete an empty subvolume just like an ordinary directory. Note that this feature only depends on the kernel version.
reduced-size metadata for extent references, saves a few percent of metadata
number of the highest supported send stream version
list of checksum algorithms supported by the kernel module, the respective modules or built-in implementing the algorithms need to be present to mount the filesystem, see CHECKSUM ALGORITHMS
list of values that are accepted as sector sizes (mkfs.btrfs --sectorsize) by the running kernel
list of values for the mount option rescue that are supported by the running kernel, see btrfs(5)
zoned mode is allocation/write friendly to host-managed zoned devices, allocation space is partitioned into fixed-size zones that must be updated sequentially, see ZONED MODE
The swapfile is supported since kernel 5.0. Use swapon(8) to activate the swapfile. There are some limitations of the implementation in btrfs and linux swap subsystem:
The limitations come namely from the COW-based design and mapping layer of blocks that allows the advanced features like relocation and multi-device filesystems. However, the swap subsystem expects simpler mapping and no background changes of the file blocks once they’ve been attached to swap.
With active swapfiles, the following whole-filesystem operations will skip swapfile extents or may fail:
When there are no active swapfiles and a whole-filesystem exclusive operation is running (ie. balance, device delete, shrink), the swapfiles cannot be temporarily activated. The operation must finish first.
To create and activate a swapfile run the following commands:
# truncate -s 0 swapfile # chattr +C swapfile # fallocate -l 2G swapfile # chmod 0600 swapfile # mkswap swapfile # swapon swapfile
Please note that the UUID returned by the mkswap utility identifies the swap "filesystem" and because it’s stored in a file, it’s not generally visible and usable as an identifier unlike if it was on a block device.
The file will appear in /proc/swaps:
# cat /proc/swaps Filename Type Size Used Priority /path/swapfile file 2097152 0 -2
The swapfile can be created as one-time operation or, once properly created, activated on each boot by the swapon -a command (usually started by the service manager). Add the following entry to /etc/fstab, assuming the filesystem that provides the /path has been already mounted at this point. Additional mount options relevant for the swapfile can be set too (like priority, not the btrfs mount options).
/path/swapfile none swap defaults 0 0
There are several checksum algorithms supported. The default and backward compatible is crc32c. Since kernel 5.5 there are three more with different characteristics and trade-offs regarding speed and strength. The following list may help you to decide which one to select.
CRC32C (32bit digest)
XXHASH (64bit digest)
SHA256 (256bit digest)
BLAKE2b (256bit digest)
The digest size affects overall size of data block checksums stored in the filesystem. The metadata blocks have a fixed area up to 256bits (32 bytes), so there’s no increase. Each data block has a separate checksum stored, with additional overhead of the b-tree leaves.
Approximate relative performance of the algorithms, measured against CRC32C using reference software implementations on a 3.5GHz intel CPU:
Many kernels are configured with SHA256 as built-in and not as a module. The accelerated versions are however provided by the modules and must be loaded explicitly (modprobe sha256) before mounting the filesystem to make use of them. You can check in /sys/fs/btrfs/FSID/checksum which one is used. If you see sha256-generic, then you may want to unmount and mount the filesystem again, changing that on a mounted filesystem is not possible. Check the file /proc/crypto, when the implementation is built-in, you’d find
name : sha256 driver : sha256-generic module : kernel priority : 100 ...
while accelerated implementation is e.g.
name : sha256 driver : sha256-avx2 module : sha256_ssse3 priority : 170 ...
Btrfs supports transparent file compression. There are three algorithms available: ZLIB, LZO and ZSTD (since v4.14). Basically, compression is on a file by file basis. You can have a single btrfs mount point that has some files that are uncompressed, some that are compressed with LZO, some with ZLIB, for instance (though you may not want it that way, it is supported).
To enable compression, mount the filesystem with options compress or compress-force. Please refer to section MOUNT OPTIONS. Once compression is enabled, all new writes will be subject to compression. Some files may not compress very well, and these are typically not recompressed but still written uncompressed.
Each compression algorithm has different speed/ratio trade offs. The levels can be selected by a mount option and affect only the resulting size (ie. no compatibility issues).
|ZLIB||slower, higher compression ratio 4 • levels: 1 to 9, mapped directly, default level is 3 4 • good backward compatibility|
|LZO||faster compression and decompression than zlib, worse compression ratio, designed to be fast 4 • no levels 4 • good backward compatibility|
|ZSTD||compression comparable to zlib with higher compression/decompression speeds and different ratio 4 • levels: 1 to 15 4 • since 4.14, levels since 5.1|
The differences depend on the actual data set and cannot be expressed by a single number or recommendation. Higher levels consume more CPU time and may not bring a significant improvement, lower levels are close to real time.
The algorithms could be mixed in one file as they’re stored per extent. The compression can be changed on a file by btrfs filesystem defrag command, using the -c option, or by btrfs property set using the compression property. Setting compression by chattr +c utility will set it to zlib.
Files with already compressed data or with data that won’t compress well with the CPU and memory constraints of the kernel implementations are using a simple decision logic. If the first portion of data being compressed is not smaller than the original, the compression of the file is disabled — unless the filesystem is mounted with compress-force. In that case compression will always be attempted on the file only to be later discarded. This is not optimal and subject to optimizations and further development.
If a file is identified as incompressible, a flag is set (NOCOMPRESS) and it’s sticky. On that file compression won’t be performed unless forced. The flag can be also set by chattr +m (since e2fsprogs 1.46.2) or by properties with value no or none. Empty value will reset it to the default that’s currently applicable on the mounted filesystem.
There are two ways to detect incompressible data:
The heuristics aim to do a few quick statistical tests on the compressed data in order to avoid probably costly compression that would turn out to be inefficient. Compression algorithms could have internal detection of incompressible data too but this leads to more overhead as the compression is done in another thread and has to write the data anyway. The heuristic is read-only and can utilize cached memory.
The tests performed based on the following: data sampling, long repated pattern detection, byte frequency, Shannon entropy.
Compression is done using the COW mechanism so it’s incompatible with nodatacow. Direct IO works on compressed files but will fall back to buffered writes. Currently nodatasum and compression don’t work together.
There are several operations that affect the whole filesystem and cannot be run in parallel. Attempt to start one while another is running will fail.
Since kernel 5.10 the currently running operation can be obtained from /sys/fs/UUID/exclusive_operation with following values and operations:
Enqueuing is supported for several btrfs subcommands so they can be started at once and then serialized.
maximum file name length
maximum symlink target length
The symlink target may not be a valid path, ie. the path name components can exceed the limits (NAME_MAX), there’s no content validation at symlink(3) creation.
maximum number of inodes
maximum file length
maximum number of subvolumes
maximum number of hardlinks of a file in a directory
minimum filesystem size
GRUB2 (https://www.gnu.org/software/grub) has the most advanced support of booting from BTRFS with respect to features.
U-boot (https://www.denx.de/wiki/U-Boot/) has decent support for booting but not all BTRFS features are implemented, check the documentation.
EXTLINUX (from the https://syslinux.org project) can boot but does not support all features. Please check the upstream documentation before you use it.
The first 1MiB on each device is unused with the exception of primary superblock that is on the offset 64KiB and spans 4KiB.
The btrfs filesystem supports setting file attributes or flags. Note there are old and new interfaces, with confusing names. The following list should clarify that:
When set on a directory, all newly created files will inherit this attribute. This attribute cannot be set with m at the same time.
When set on a directory, all newly created files will inherit this attribute.
due to implementation limitations, this flag can be set/unset only on empty files.
When set on a directory, all newly created files will inherit this attribute. This attribute cannot be set with c at the same time.
No other attributes are supported. For the complete list please refer to the chattr(1) manual page.
There’s overlap of letters assigned to the bits with the attributes, this list refers to what xfs_io(8) provides:
Since version 5.12 btrfs supports so called zoned mode. This is a special on-disk format and allocation/write strategy that’s friendly to zoned devices. In short, a device is partitioned into fixed-size zones and each zone can be updated by append-only manner, or reset. As btrfs has no fixed data structures, except the super blocks, the zoned mode only requires block placement that follows the device constraints. You can learn about the whole architecture at https://zonedstorage.io .
The devices are also called SMR/ZBC/ZNS, in host-managed mode. Note that there are devices that appear as non-zoned but actually are, this is drive-managed and using zoned mode won’t help.
The zone size depends on the device, typical sizes are 256MiB or 1GiB. In general it must be a power of two. Emulated zoned devices like null_blk allow to set various zone sizes.
The main constraint of the zoned devices is lack of in-place update of the data. This is inherently incompatbile with some features:
Initial support lacks some features but they’re planned:
As said above, super block is handled in a special way. In order to be crash safe, at least one zone in a known location must contain a valid superblock. This is implemented as a ring buffer in two consecutive zones, starting from known offsets 0, 512G and 4TiB. The values are different than on non-zoned devices. Each new super block is appended to the end of the zone, once it’s filled, the zone is reset and writes continue to the next one. Looking up the latest super block needs to read offsets of both zones and determine the last written version.
The amount of space reserved for super block depends on the zone size. The secondary and tertiary copies are at distant offsets as the capacity of the devices is expected to be large, tens of terabytes. Maximum zone size supported is 8GiB, which would mean that eg. offset 0-16GiB would be reserved just for the super block on a hypothetical device of that zone size. This is wasteful but required to guarantee crash safety.
There’s a character special device /dev/btrfs-control with major and minor numbers 10 and 234 (the device can be found under the misc category).
$ ls -l /dev/btrfs-control crw------- 1 root root 10, 234 Jan 1 12:00 /dev/btrfs-control
The device accepts some ioctl calls that can perform following actions on the filesystem module:
The device is created when btrfs is initialized, either as a module or a built-in functionality and makes sense only in connection with that. Running eg. mkfs without the module loaded will not register the device and will probably warn about that.
In rare cases when the module is loaded but the device is not present (most likely accidentally deleted), it’s possible to recreate it by
# mknod --mode=600 /dev/btrfs-control c 10 234
or (since 5.11) by a convenience command
# btrfs rescue create-control-device
The control device is not strictly required but the device scanning will not work and a workaround would need to be used to mount a multi-device filesystem. The mount option device can trigger the device scanning during mount, see also btrfs device scan.
It is possible that a btrfs filesystem contains multiple block group profiles of the same type. This could happen when a profile conversion using balance filters is interrupted (see btrfs-balance(8)). Some btrfs commands perform a test to detect this kind of condition and print a warning like this:
WARNING: Multiple block group profiles detected, see 'man btrfs(5)'. WARNING: Data: single, raid1 WARNING: Metadata: single, raid1
The corresponding output of btrfs filesystem df might look like:
WARNING: Multiple block group profiles detected, see 'man btrfs(5)'. WARNING: Data: single, raid1 WARNING: Metadata: single, raid1 Data, RAID1: total=832.00MiB, used=0.00B Data, single: total=1.63GiB, used=0.00B System, single: total=4.00MiB, used=16.00KiB Metadata, single: total=8.00MiB, used=112.00KiB Metadata, RAID1: total=64.00MiB, used=32.00KiB GlobalReserve, single: total=16.25MiB, used=0.00B
There’s more than one line for type Data and Metadata, while the profiles are single and RAID1.
This state of the filesystem OK but most likely needs the user/administrator to take an action and finish the interrupted tasks. This cannot be easily done automatically, also the user knows the expected final profiles.
In the example above, the filesystem started as a single device and single block group profile. Then another device was added, followed by balance with convert=raid1 but for some reason hasn’t finished. Restarting the balance with convert=raid1 will continue and end up with filesystem with all block group profiles RAID1.
If you’re familiar with balance filters, you can use convert=raid1,profiles=single,soft, which will take only the unconverted single profiles and convert them to raid1. This may speed up the conversion as it would not try to rewrite the already convert raid1 profiles.
Having just one profile is desired as this also clearly defines the profile of newly allocated block groups, otherwise this depends on internal allocation policy. When there are multiple profiles present, the order of selection is RAID6, RAID5, RAID10, RAID1, RAID0 as long as the device number constraints are satisfied.
Commands that print the warning were chosen so they’re brought to user attention when the filesystem state is being changed in that regard. This is: device add, device delete, balance cancel, balance pause. Commands that report space usage: filesystem df, device usage. The command filesystem usage provides a line in the overall summary:
Multiple profiles: yes (data, metadata)
The COW mechanism and multiple devices under one hood enable an interesting concept, called a seeding device: extending a read-only filesystem on a single device filesystem with another device that captures all writes. For example imagine an immutable golden image of an operating system enhanced with another device that allows to use the data from the golden image and normal operation. This idea originated on CD-ROMs with base OS and allowing to use them for live systems, but this became obsolete. There are technologies providing similar functionality, like unionmount, overlayfs or qcow2 image snapshot.
The seeding device starts as a normal filesystem, once the contents is ready, btrfstune -S 1 is used to flag it as a seeding device. Mounting such device will not allow any writes, except adding a new device by btrfs device add. Then the filesystem can be remounted as read-write.
Given that the filesystem on the seeding device is always recognized as read-only, it can be used to seed multiple filesystems, at the same time. The UUID that is normally attached to a device is automatically changed to a random UUID on each mount.
Once the seeding device is mounted, it needs the writable device. After adding it, something like remount -o remount,rw /path makes the filesystem at /path ready for use. The simplest usecase is to throw away all changes by unmounting the filesystem when convenient.
Alternatively, deleting the seeding device from the filesystem can turn it into a normal filesystem, provided that the writable device can also contain all the data from the seeding device.
The seeding device flag can be cleared again by btrfstune -f -s 0, eg. allowing to update with newer data but please note that this will invalidate all existing filesystems that use this particular seeding device. This works for some usecases, not for others, and a forcing flag to the command is mandatory to avoid accidental mistakes.
Example how to create and use one seeding device:
# mkfs.btrfs /dev/sda # mount /dev/sda /mnt/mnt1 # ... fill mnt1 with data # umount /mnt/mnt1 # btrfstune -S 1 /dev/sda # mount /dev/sda /mnt/mnt1 # btrfs device add /dev/sdb /mnt # mount -o remount,rw /mnt/mnt1 # ... /mnt/mnt1 is now writable
Now /mnt/mnt1 can be used normally. The device /dev/sda can be mounted again with a another writable device:
# mount /dev/sda /mnt/mnt2 # btrfs device add /dev/sdc /mnt/mnt2 # mount -o remount,rw /mnt/mnt2 # ... /mnt/mnt2 is now writable
The writable device (/dev/sdb) can be decoupled from the seeding device and used independently:
# btrfs device delete /dev/sda /mnt/mnt1
As the contents originated in the seeding device, it’s possible to turn /dev/sdb to a seeding device again and repeat the whole process.
A few things to note:
The RAID56 feature provides striping and parity over several devices, same as the traditional RAID5/6. There are some implementation and design deficiencies that make it unreliable for some corner cases and the feature should not be used in production, only for evaluation or testing. The power failure safety for metadata with RAID56 is not 100%.
Do not use raid5 nor raid6 for metadata. Use raid1 or raid1c3 respectively.
The substitute profiles provide the same guarantees against loss of 1 or 2 devices, and in some respect can be an improvement. Recovering from one missing device will only need to access the remaining 1st or 2nd copy, that in general may be stored on some other devices due to the way RAID1 works on btrfs, unlike on a striped profile (similar to raid0) that would need all devices all the time.
The space allocation pattern and consumption is different (eg. on N devices): for raid5 as an example, a 1GiB chunk is reserved on each device, while with raid1 there’s each 1GiB chunk stored on 2 devices. The consumption of each 1GiB of used metadata is then N * 1GiB for vs 2 * 1GiB. Using raid1 is also more convenient for balancing/converting to other profile due to lower requirement on the available chunk space.
When RAID56 is on the same filesystem with different raid profiles, the space reporting is inaccurate, eg. df, btrfs filesystem df or btrfs filesystem usge. When there’s only a one profile per block group type (eg. raid5 for data) the reporting is accurate.
When scrub is started on a RAID56 filesystem, it’s started on all devices that degrade the performance. The workaround is to start it on each device separately. Due to that the device stats may not match the actual state and some errors might get reported multiple times.
The write hole problem.
A storage model is a model that captures key physical aspects of data structure in a data store. A filesystem is the logical structure organizing data on top of the storage device.
The filesystem assumes several features or limitations of the storage device and utilizes them or applies measures to guarantee reliability. BTRFS in particular is based on a COW (copy on write) mode of writing, ie. not updating data in place but rather writing a new copy to a different location and then atomically switching the pointers.
In an ideal world, the device does what it promises. The filesystem assumes that this may not be true so additional mechanisms are applied to either detect misbehaving hardware or get valid data by other means. The devices may (and do) apply their own detection and repair mechanisms but we won’t assume any.
The following assumptions about storage devices are considered (sorted by importance, numbers are for further reference):
The consistency model of BTRFS builds on these assumptions. The logical data updates are grouped, into a generation, written on the device, serialized by the flush command and then the super block is written ending the generation. All logical links among metadata comprising a consistent view of the data may not cross the generation boundary.
No or partial atomicity of block reads/writes (1)
The flush command does not flush (2)
This is perhaps the most serious problem and impossible to mitigate by filesystem without limitations and design restrictions. What could happen in the worst case is that writes from one generation bleed to another one, while still letting the filesystem consider the generations isolated. Crash at any point would leave data on the device in an inconsistent state without any hint what exactly got written, what is missing and leading to stale metadata link information.
Devices usually honor the flush command, but for performance reasons may do internal caching, where the flushed data are not yet persistently stored. A power failure could lead to a similar scenario as above, although it’s less likely that later writes would be written before the cached ones. This is beyond what a filesystem can take into account. Devices or controllers are usually equipped with batteries or capacitors to write the cache contents even after power is cut. (Battery backed write cache)
Data get silently changed on write (3)
Such thing should not happen frequently, but still can happen spuriously due the complex internal workings of devices or physical effects of the storage media itself.
Data get silently written to another offset (3)
This would be another serious problem as the filesystem has no information when it happens. For that reason the measures have to be done ahead of time. This problem is also commonly called ghost write.
The metadata blocks have the checksum embedded in the blocks, so a correct atomic write would not corrupt the checksum. It’s likely that after reading such block the data inside would not be consistent with the rest. To rule that out there’s embedded block number in the metadata block. It’s the logical block number because this is what the logical structure expects and verifies.
The following is based on information publicly available, user feedback, community discussions or bug report analyses. It’s not complete and further research is encouraged when in doubt.
The data structures and raw data blocks are temporarily stored in computer memory before they get written to the device. It is critical that memory is reliable because even simple bit flips can have vast consequences and lead to damaged structures, not only in the filesystem but in the whole operating system.
Based on experience in the community, memory bit flips are more common than one would think. When it happens, it’s reported by the tree-checker or by a checksum mismatch after reading blocks. There are some very obvious instances of bit flips that happen, e.g. in an ordered sequence of keys in metadata blocks. We can easily infer from the other data what values get damaged and how. However, fixing that is not straightforward and would require cross-referencing data from the entire filesystem to see the scope.
If available, ECC memory should lower the chances of bit flips, but this type of memory is not available in all cases. A memory test should be performed in case there’s a visible bit flip pattern, though this may not detect a faulty memory module because the actual load of the system could be the factor making the problems appear. In recent years attacks on how the memory modules operate have been demonstrated (rowhammer) achieving specific bits to be flipped. While these were targeted, this shows that a series of reads or writes can affect unrelated parts of memory.
What to do:
Another class of errors is related to DMA (direct memory access) performed by device drivers. While this could be considered a software error, the data transfers that happen without CPU assistance may accidentally corrupt other pages. Storage devices utilize DMA for performance reasons, the filesystem structures and data pages are passed back and forth, making errors possible in case page life time is not properly tracked.
There are lots of quirks (device-specific workarounds) in Linux kernel drivers (regarding not only DMA) that are added when found. The quirks may avoid specific errors or disable some features to avoid worse problems.
What to do:
Rotational HDDs typically fail at the level of individual sectors or small clusters. Read failures are caught on the levels below the filesystem and are returned to the user as EIO - Input/output error. Reading the blocks repeatedly may return the data eventually, but this is better done by specialized tools and filesystem takes the result of the lower layers. Rewriting the sectors may trigger internal remapping but this inevitably leads to data loss.
Disk firmware is technically software but from the filesystem perspective is part of the hardware. IO requests are processed, and caching or various other optimizations are performed, which may lead to bugs under high load or unexpected physical conditions or unsupported use cases.
Disks are connected by cables with two ends, both of which can cause problems when not attached properly. Data transfers are protected by checksums and the lower layers try hard to transfer the data correctly or not at all. The errors from badly-connecting cables may manifest as large amount of failed read or write requests, or as short error bursts depending on physical conditions.
What to do:
The mechanism of information storage is different from HDDs and this affects the failure mode as well. The data are stored in cells grouped in large blocks with limited number of resets and other write constraints. The firmware tries to avoid unnecessary resets and performs optimizations to maximize the storage media lifetime. The known techniques are deduplication (blocks with same fingerprint/hash are mapped to same physical block), compression or internal remapping and garbage collection of used memory cells. Due to the additional processing there are measures to verity the data e.g. by ECC codes.
The observations of failing SSDs show that the whole electronic fails at once or affects a lot of data (eg. stored on one chip). Recovering such data may need specialized equipment and reading data repeatedly does not help as it’s possible with HDDs.
There are several technologies of the memory cells with different characteristics and price. The lifetime is directly affected by the type and frequency of data written. Writing "too much" distinct data (e.g. encrypted) may render the internal deduplication ineffective and lead to a lot of rewrites and increased wear of the memory cells.
There are several technologies and manufacturers so it’s hard to describe them but there are some that exhibit similar behaviour:
It’s not possible to reliably determine the expected lifetime of an SSD due to lack of information about how it works or due to lack of reliable stats provided by the device.
Metadata writes tend to be the biggest component of lifetime writes to a SSD, so there is some value in reducing them. Depending on the device class (high end/low end) the features like DUP block group profiles may affect the reliability in both ways:
Only users who consume 50 to 100% of the SSD’s actual lifetime writes need to be concerned by the write amplification of btrfs DUP metadata. Most users will be far below 50% of the actual lifetime, or will write the drive to death and discover how many writes 100% of the actual lifetime was. SSD firmware often adds its own write multipliers that can be arbitrary and unpredictable and dependent on application behavior, and these will typically have far greater effect on SSD lifespan than DUP metadata. It’s more or less impossible to predict when a SSD will run out of lifetime writes to within a factor of two, so it’s hard to justify wear reduction as a benefit.
What to do:
NVMe is a type of persistent memory usually connected over a system bus (PCIe) or similar interface and the speeds are an order of magnitude faster than SSD. It is also a non-rotating type of storage, and is not typically connected by a cable. It’s not a SCSI type device either but rather a complete specification for logical device interface.
In a way the errors could be compared to a combination of SSD class and regular memory. Errors may exhibit as random bit flips or IO failures. There are tools to access the internal log (nvme log and nvme-cli) for a more detailed analysis.
There are separate error detection and correction steps performed e.g. on the bus level and in most cases never making in to the filesystem level. Once this happens it could mean there’s some systematic error like overheating or bad physical connection of the device. You may want to run self-tests (using smartctl).
Firmware is technically still software but embedded into the hardware. As all software has bugs, so does firmware. Storage devices can update the firmware and fix known bugs. In some cases the it’s possible to avoid certain bugs by quirks (device-specific workarounds) in Linux kernel.
A faulty firmware can cause wide range of corruptions from small and localized to large affecting lots of data. Self-repair capabilities may not be sufficient.
What to do:
There are a lot of devices with low power consumption and thus using storage media based on low power consumption too, typically flash memory stored on a chip enclosed in a detachable card package. An improperly inserted card may be damaged by electrical spikes when the device is turned on or off. The chips storing data in turn may be damaged permanently. All types of flash memory have a limited number of rewrites, so the data are internally translated by FTL (flash translation layer). This is implemented in firmware (technically a software) and prone to bugs that manifest as hardware errors.
Adding redundancy like using DUP profiles for both data and metadata can help in some cases but a full backup might be the best option once problems appear and replacing the card could be required as well.
If you use unreliable hardware and don’t know about that, don’t blame the filesystem when it tells you.